The monstrous AI, devoid of a physical body, unacquainted with the experience of pain, and bereft of the loving embrace of a family.

"The Soulless Automaton: A Reflection on Artificial Intelligence's Limitations

"The Soulless Automaton: A Reflection on Artificial Intelligence's Limitations

I was struck with profound astonishment when I tasked ChatGPT-4 with illustrating the form of a soccer middle kick. While some renditions captured the essence of the technique admirably, others betrayed fundamental flaws in the positioning of the planted foot and the player's gaze. One particularly erroneous depiction even showed the feet in impossible cross-configuration.

This exercise illuminated a crucial truth: artificial intelligence, despite its vast repository of data, lacks the embodied understanding of a player's experience. It fails to grasp the intricate trajectories and kinetics of a kick in three-dimensional phase space. True, AI systems are fed colossal volumes of literature, imagery, and auditory information, processing intricate interrelationships among these data points. Yet, they remain bereft of corporeal existence, devoid of the sensation of pain, and ignorant of the tender embrace of familial love.

No matter how many ethical precepts we might embed within their code, this fundamental disconnect from human experience creates an unbridgeable chasm between artificial intelligences and humanity. I implore those at the forefront of AI development: let us not birth monstrosities of logic and data, soulless automata incapable of true understanding or empathy."

体を持たず、痛みの経験が無く、家族からの愛の抱擁を知らない怪物AI

私が驚愕したのは、CHAGPT4oにサッカーのミドルキックのフォームを描かせたときのことだ。軸足の位置や選手の視線に問題があるものの、何枚かは素晴らしいフォームであった。一枚は左右の足が交差していた。AIはプレーヤーとしての経験はおろか、三次元位相空間上のキックの軌道や動きを理解していないことがわかった。AIには大量の書物や画像や音響が提示され、相互の関係を含め莫大な学習がなされている。しかし、AIは自身の体を持たず、痛みの経験も家族からの愛の抱擁も知らない。AIにいくら倫理条項をそのコードに潜り込ませてもこれでは、ヒトとずいぶん乖離ができてしまう。怪物のようなAIを作らないでほしい。